Tuesday, 21 January 2020

D: Goblin Lair

Day four and it's the turn of the Goblins...
With this section I drew the stairs the wrong way round and had to re-do them - in the original map key it has "stairs up" and "stairs down" but in the middle of a corridor that tells you nothing!

I need to mark the fireplace in #19, and the Chieftain's Room shows I need better pens - I've got some on order. For these lair maps I also should add the letter for the adjoining sections.

This map is an unusual shape which I thought was a problem - on a two-page dungeon spread you'd have to put this diagonally across the page with the key top right and bottom left - but this would make for an interesting layout.

I was surprised there's no lock on the door joining the Goblins to the Hobgoblins, it's not even jammed - they are simply "watching the door" and "battle ready" - which seems highly unlikely.

The oddest thing about the lair however is the dead-end passageways. There are no less than eight dead-ends on this section, whereas there are only two other true dead-ends in the entire rest of the map (excepting two 10' square alcoves). There's no indication of their purpose, and game-wise all but one of them you can see to the end without going down it. Functionally they might act as time-wasters so you get got by a wandering monster whilst searching for a secret door... It is odd to find such a high concentration so they really deserve some explanation. Harder rock that couldn't be mined? Or a rockfall joining each pair of dead ends together? The right hand dead end looks like a natural cave so could have something unusual.

It looks like tomorrow is going to be a short post.

Monday, 20 January 2020

C: Orc Lair #2

Welcome to The Caves Of Chaos day 3 - and the mystery of the fireplaces!

Regarding contents I've added the net trap, and clarified that there's a guard outside the  leader's room, and the secret meeting room is duplicated on the map as it's shared with the last lair.

The oddity on the map is the alcove in the common room. I kept all the roughness of the walls on purpose - deciding that it was on purpose, not just an overly rough map. Room #9 has an oddity that could be an alcove which matches up to the "great fireplace on the south wall" in the description. Room #30 refers to "near the fireplace (southeast corner)" which matches an alcove on the map. Room #38 refers to a fireplace (no location specified) and there's an alcove on the north wall, likewise a reference with no location in #50 and an alcove on the map.

Hence I think it's likely that most of the alcoves on the map are supposed to be fireplaces, including #15 (Common Hall) here, and similarly earlier at #6 (Common Chamber) which is slightly less pronounced on my map than the original. Looking for other suspect alcoves we see one in #19 (Common Room), and finally one in #25 (Common Chamber).

That puts fireplaces in the common room of every humanoid lair, except for the Gnolls who have theirs in the Chieftain's Room!

I've not seen fireplaces drawn on other people's version of the map, and I've often seen the alcoves changed/reduced/removed. So when I collate the maps at the end of this series I'll include fireplaces as an amendment. I think they were clear on Gary's original map, and got lost when it got redrawn. Similarly I think it is on purpose that #58 (Temple of Evil Chaos) has very straight walls on the map when everything else is slightly rough.

Tomorrow we jump across to the other side of the ravine!

Sunday, 19 January 2020

B: Orc Lair #1

Here's day 2 of my map-a-day-athon. Orc lair #1:

The obvious new thing about this second map is that I've included the corridor beyond the secret door in grey - other maps I've seen include interconnected lairs in the same map, which isn't helpful when running the game. I'd put the map for each lair along with the room descriptions, at the same scale as the overall map.

This map also reveals some minor issues about the original map. Several lairs have items of interest at or near the entrance that are only mentioned in the Lair entry, so are easy to forget when running the game. For this lair it's the heads in niches on the wall, which I've marked on the map as a reminder.

Secondly, the guard at 9 is supposed to stick his head through the wall and pretend is head is one of the trophies, then when he spots intruders replace it with a Goblin head and go to room #7 for help - except that he can't get to that room!

For #12 Orc Leader's Room the original map has just one tapestry on the west wall. The description says "The room is carpeted, has tapestries upon the walls (note one of these covers the entrance to the cave to the west)" but then later says "If hard pressed, the leader will wiggle behind the tapestries on the south wall and attempt to work the catch on the secret door to the south". When DMing it's fine if no tapestries are marked on the map, or all of them, but it's misleading to have just one, especially when there's a second important one.

Finally - what's that loop on the south side on room #9 supposed to be? As I was working on all the other maps I wondered if that's supposed to be the fireplace mentioned in the description? We'll consider possible fireplaces on the map again tomorrow in the second Orc Lair.

Saturday, 18 January 2020

A: Kobold Lair

I've been silent on the blog for a long while - still playing and still tweaking rules - but no blogging. A week or so ago my eldest said she was thinking of running D&D at college and wanted to run the first adventure she'd ever played through, she thought it wouldn't be too hard for a first time DM to run.

There are a few issues with the presentation of the module, so I decided to revise it slightly to make it easier to run. Initially I was just going to add some names, then I thought I'd revise how the room information was presented to make it clearer, then I thought I'd redraw the maps.

I'm going to post one map a day for this project, starting with the map for A: Kobold Lair. I'm sure you'll all have spotted which adventure it's from:


The shading is familiar - it's an old style I've always liked as I noted in a previous post, but one made popular in the last 10 years by Dyson Logos. You need some form of shading for maps where the corridors are the same width as the spaces between them. Previously for my maps I'd shaded the whole background in grey, but it makes it a bit oppressive. Shading just near the walls is better, as it just makes the walls stand out, but if you do that in a block colour it looks odd. The cross-hatch shading works as the irregular nature of the shading works well with an irregular border.

I could have used the version Dyson himself drew of the map, but it has grid squares drawn over it which makes it cluttered, and it gives me no room for the extra info I want on the map. It's fun to draw maps, and I thought it would be interesting to compare afterwards to see where I could improve.

I did the lairs one at a time, then combined them all into one single map which I've printed out on A3 card. This lair was the first, as is clear from the fact that the density of my shading has changed slightly as I drew it.

I put the name of the rooms - enough to remind you on the fly what it is - but often not the whole name (as it gets too cluttered). I used to mark on all creatures, but now I just make room descriptions clearer so it's not necessary. I do sometimes mark the creatures directly on the map when I'm doing one-page dungeon style - but in that case I have more space as there's no room number.

I have shaded in the locked door to the store as that's a detail I used to got wrong when I started out DMing, and it's very easy to mark.

I may add back in a light grid at some point, but it's not that necessary as I draw the players' map on thin see-through paper as I talked about before.

Tuesday, 4 July 2017

Concept Driven Character Creation

I spent a long time pondering how best to present the process of creating a character in Explore; simple practical steps that would allow you to quickly create a character you were happy with. Although it seems simple enough - allocate the bonuses to your attributes and spend points on skills - they are interlinked decisions. Of particular importance is this: the first time you create a character it should be an opportunity to learn how the game works, it should not be necessary to first gain an in-depth knowledge of the rules to make sensible decisions.

In the end I realised that not only did I have three fundamentally different approaches to creating a character - further it is actually desirable to have different methods. None of these is a "better method" than the others, and I like all three for different reasons.

Method A: Attribute First

This is the "purest" method. You create a raw, untrained character that matches your concept, and then develop them with skills you feel appropriate.

Choose three attributes which describe your character well (e.g. "tall", "athletic", "intuitive" ) and three which the opposite describes your character well (e.g. "slight", "poor memory", no "soul").

This should be a reasonable start for a description of your character.

Put a bonus of 2 in the attributes which described your character well, 0 in those where the opposite was true, and 1 in the remainder.

For example the character described above gets:
Height
2
Dexterity
1
Intuition
2
Build
0
Coordination
1
Memory
0
Athletic
2
Quickness
1
Empathy
1
Toughness
1
Perception
1
Soul
0

From this fill in you character sheet to see what bonuses your character has in different skills. This should confirm that your character has a natural advantage in the skills and saves you would expect from your character description. If not, then revisit your choices (or fix the rules!)

In our example we have:
+4: Muscle:Kill, Muscle:Lift, Melee, Unarmed, Thrown, Bows, [Parry], Muscle:Acrobatics, Muscle:Run, Thief, Scout, [Artefacts]
+3: [Body], Muscle:Sprint, Wilderness, Ride, [Directed Spells], [Observation], Language, Lore, [Detect Magic]
+2: Healer, [Psychic Attack], Music, Art, Dancing, [Runes], Craft
+1: [Psychic Defence]

Note for purposes of spending points on skills note that you don't spend points on the items in [brackets] - these are skills you get for free. Also note the various Muscle: items are all aspects of a single skill "Muscle" - you spend points on Muscle and then decide which aspects of Muscle to improve (power, speed or acrobatics).

Next, as your character, choose what skills you want to learn. You may want to improve weak areas, or concentrate on things you're naturally good at.

Our character has a clear non-magical inclination. They have quite a broad range of skills at +4, and looking at their +4 in kills and bows but only +3 in body decide to concentrate not on straight-up combat but a more sneaky approach, taking as main skills scout, bows, & muscle (for kill).


Method C: Class First

This is the most traditional method and the easiest to understand. You select a standard character class which comes with a standard set of abilities, and advice on how to distribute the attribute bonuses.

Select a class you wish to play. Each class advises which attributes are important for that class, and which are unimportant. Put your 2s in three of the important attributes, 0s in three of the unimportant attributes.

For example, a Warrior's primary focus is Melee fighting. Hence their primary four skills are Melee, Kill, Parry, and Body. All four are of equal importance and use attributes CQI, HBA, CQA, HBT. Height, Build, Athletics, Coordination and Quickness all give bonuses to two skills. Intuition helps with Observation, and Toughness helps with Psychic Defence - both also key skills for a warrior. Hence the description of the Warrior class lists as important attributes Height, Build, Toughness, Athletics, Coordination, Quickness, and Intuition.

In contrast Dexterity, Memory, Empathy and Soul give bonuses to few useful skills, so these are listed as the least important attributes.

We choose Height, Build, and Quickness to be +2, and Dexterity, Memory and Empathy to be 0; the rest are 0.

When the character sheet is completed this gives us: (with relevant skills for a Warrior in bold).
+5: Muscle:Kill, Body, Muscle:Lift, Muscle:Sprint
+4: Melee, Unarmed, [Parry], Muscle:Run, Muscle:Acrobatics, Dancing
+3: Ride, Scout, Bows, Thrown, [Detect Magic], [Directed Spells]
+2: [Observation], [Psychic Defence], Thief, Wilderness, Art, Lore, [Psychic Attack], [Runes]
+1: Music, Language, Healer

Method S: Skills First

This is the most complicated method, one which is focused on getting the best bonuses for your character.

Select two or three key skills you want your character to be good at, then place the +2 bonuses in your attributes one at a time, selecting them to maximise your key skills, filling in these bonuses against the relevant skills. When you have placed all your +2 bonuses, place your +1s to complete your key skills, and then use the remaining +1s to ensure a balanced character, or place your 0s in attributes you won't benefit from. In this method you often switch around where your bonuses are several times to create the character you desire.

For example we want our character to be good at Scout, Bows and Muscle:Kill. (Bows to hit the target, Kill for the strength to shoot a strong bow). That means the key attributes are CPI, DPI, and HBA. We only have three +2s to spread out, so we put them in Perception, Intuition (both shared with Scout and Bows) and save one for Muscle:Kill. Since Athletics gives us a bonus also on Parry we put our last +2 there. To keep a good bonus in each of these four skills we don't want to then put a 0 in HBCDQ - which only leaves Toughness, Memory, Empathy and Soul. We don't want Body of less than 3 (the average) so opt to put the zeros in MES.

This gives the following bonuses:

+5: Bows, Scout, Thief, Thrown
+4: Muscle:Kill, [Parry], [Observation], Melee, Wilderness, Unarmed, Muscle:Lift, Muscle:Acrobatics, Muscle:Sprint, Muscle:Run, [Psychic Attack], [Detect Magic], Lore
+3: [Body], Healer, Art
+2: Ride, [Directed Spells], [Runes], Dancing, Language
+1: [Psychic Defence], Music

We buy rank 3 in Bows, Scout and Muscle (3*4=12 points), rank 2 in Melee (2 points), and rank 1 in Thief and Wilderness (total 16 points = level 1).
We don't bother spending any points on Thrown, despite our natural ability in it.
We get some of the skills in brackets for free - we get rank 1 in Body and Psychic Defence (as we're 16 points = level 1), rank 4 in Parry (for the 10 points spent on Bows, Muscle and Melee), rank 3 in Observation (for the 6 points spent on Scout, Thief and Wilderness).
We don't get any ranks in Runes, Detect Magic, Psychic Attack or Directed Spells as we've not spent points on spells.

We also get some points to spend on the "secondary skills" - Lore, Art, Dancing, Language, Music. These should probably be in another font to show they're different.

Note that this character has no +6s and no +0s - it is not what you would expect from a Min/Max character optimisation. Also they have ended up with a weak spot - only a +1 in Psychic Defence. There is no "best" allocation of points - which should mean you avoid cookie cutter characters despite the lack of random attribute generation.

Summary

As you can see, both Attributes or Class first are simple enough systems. Make some simple decisions and copy the numbers on to the character sheet and you're done.

The Skills first system requires you to understand the system, so is difficult to explain directly, but once you have done either of the other two systems a couple of times you should understand how the system works and anyone could do Skills first. I find that after I have created a character via this method I tinker a bit with swapping attributes about to get the best fit, and I think that's probably helped by having a trivial spreadsheet (or online form) so you can quickly play around with different choices and see the effect.

For the completed rules I'm planning on one chapter being entirely about creating class based characters using the Class first Method (i.e. a step by step creation process), then a second about creating skill based characters starting with the Attributes first Method, then a brief explanation about the Skills first Method.

Probably that's the next thing I should be working on - the two chapters on creating a character in a logical order.

Tuesday, 27 June 2017

Attributes and Related Skills

So, here it is - my new attribute system that I'm sad to say has taken me the last five months to get into shape.

Overview

Attributes are broad brush bonuses to represent aspects of your character to give consistent characters. Aspects of your character which you role play (problem solving, personality / conversations) are not covered by attributes, nor are physical attractiveness or luck.

Each attribute is a bonus of 0,1,2 and three attributes bonuses apply to each skill, giving each skill a bonus between 0 and 6.


Related Skills

Attribute bonuses tell you something specific about the character, and have little or no overlap. In contrast, because related skills share some (or all) attributes, related skills have similar bonuses.

The following diagram shows which skills share two or more attributes, and hence which have similar bonuses:

For example, Thown and Scout share all three attributes, so share a box. These skills have the same bonus.
Healer, Bows, Thief and Art all share (Manual) Dexterity and Perception, so are joined by lines going to a circle marked "DP". These skills have bonus within 2 points of each other. (I'm amused that Artists and Thieves are closely related!)

This diagram allows you to not only to spot related skills, but to spot skills that should be related (but aren't) or skills that are related (but shouldn't be). This allowed me to spot flaws in the system and hence refine it. Note that all skills are related to at least one other skill.

This is an evolution of the previous system where Kill & Lift were linked to Body because the first pair using STR whereas Body used CON which was a linked attribute. If I drew a related skill diagram for the previous system however it would be extremely sparse and simplistic.

The Attributes

Height (Tall/Short)
Being taller also makes you heavier and thus stronger and resilient.

Build (Broad/Slight)
Being broad makes you heavier and thus stronger and resilient.

Athletic
This makes you stronger, but not heavier, thus improving your power-to-weight ratio.

Toughness
Includes endurance / stamina, and resilience to damage or poison.

Dexterity
This is manual dexterity - coordinated finger and hand movements.

Coordination
The ability to move the body smoothly in a controlled fashion. It includes balance, hand-eye co-ordination, and proprioception.

Quickness
The ability to make the body respond and move quickly (but not necessarily with any power behind it).

Perception
The ability to notice things with the senses - for example judge how far it is to the tree, or how windy it is, or to notice a damp patch on the floor - but not to infer anything from them.

Intuition
The ability to make inferences without conscious logical thought - for example to draw conclusions from your perceptions as to what is important.

Memory
The ability to learn and recall knowledge. Note that most skills require you to remember things - memory only helps skills which require large amounts of memorising.

Empathy
The ability to understand and interpret the feelings of others. It has a supernatural side, similar to sensing someone's aura.

Soul
This is both the artistic soul, and the magical soul.

Attribute Bonuses

Which attributes apply to each skill and save is described below, along with an explanation of why the attribute applies. This should clarify further what the attributes mean.

Note that two combinations of attributes are repeated several times:

- Coordination + Quickness combined form overall Agility.

- All ranged attacks (thrown / bows / directed spells) use  Perception (for sensing the target), and Intuition (for judgements such as the distance to the target)

Note that in some cases the attribute helps in learning the skill which thus indirectly helps in performing the activity. Similarly if the attribute mostly helps then that positive reinforcement helps you improve at the skill which makes you better in general.

Runes
Soul (to sense the magic in the runes), Memory (to remember Rune Lore), Intuition (to apply the rune lore).

Detect Magic
Soul (to sense the magical aura), Perception (to sense the physical manifestations of the magic), Intuition (to sift through the sensory information and determine what is magical).

Dancing
Soul (for artistic performance), Coordination and Quickness (for overall agility).

Art (Painting / Sculpture)
Soul (for artistic ability), Perception (for seeing the world), Dexterity (for handling the tools).

Music (by Instrument)
Soul (for artistic performance), Empathy (for a performance with feeling), Dexterity (to play fast / complex music).

Lore (by Subject)
Memory (to remember the lore), Perception (to examine things - both when learning and when applying the lore), Intuition (to apply the lore).

Language
Memory (to remember the words/grammar etc), Intuition (to apply it in unfamiliar situations, to improve), Empathy (picking up emotional signals helps communication).

Observation
Perception (to notice things), Intuition (to sift through what you notice to spot relevant things or draw inferences), Memory (to remember what things should look like and thus spot inconsistencies, or simply to recall prior hiding places).

Directed Spells
Soul (for controlling the magic), Perception + Intuition (for ranged attack).

Psychic Defence
Soul (for sensing the attack magically), Toughness (for resisting the attack physically), Memory (for resisting the attack mentally).

Psychic Attack
Soul (for controlling the magic), Perception (for sensing the target physically), Empathy (for sensing the target mentally).

Ride
Coordination and Quickness (for the required physical agility), Empathy (for connecting emotionally with the mount).

Healer
Perception (to correctly perceive the problem), Memory (to remember what to look for and what to do), Dexterity (to fix the problem).

Scout (Sneak / Hide)
Perception (to spot the squeaky floorboard), Intuition (to work out where to stand so you remain in shadow), and Coordination (to step over the squeaky floorboard carefully).

Thief (Pick lock / disarm trap / pick pockets)
Perception (to examine the trap/lock carefully), Intuition (to work out how to disarm this particular trap), and Dexterity (to disarm it with steady hands).

Wilderness (Navigate / track / survival / snares / forage)
Perception (to notice the tracks), Intuition (to judge where to look when the tracks vanish), Memory (to remember what animal makes those tracks). Wilderness is highly related to Observation but here the Memory bonus is recalling all the miscellaneous facts / sights / sounds / smells of the wilderness.

Run
Athletics (for power-to-weight ratio), Toughness (for endurance - being able to maintain the speed), Quickness (for speed of movement of limbs).

Sprint
Athletics (for power-to-weight ratio), Build (for muscle bulk for an explosive acceleration), Quickness (for speed of movement of limbs).

Acrobatics
Athletics (for power-to-weight ratio), Coordination + Quickness (for overall agility).

Parry / Dodge
Coordination + Quickness (for agility), Athletics either as per Acrobatics (for Dodge) or for blocking the blow (for Parry).

Bows
Perception + Intuition (for ranged attack), Dexterity (for accurate controlled releasing of the bow).

Thrown
Perception + Intuition (for ranged attack), Coordination (for accurate throwing motion).

Melee & Unarmed
Coordination + Quickness (for agility), Intuition (for selecting the best attack opportunity).

Body
Height + Build (for pure bulk), Toughness (for resistance to damage).

Kill & Lift
Height + Build (for strength from bulk), Athletics (for power-to-weight ratio).

Note that all attributes give a bonus to at least one offensive or defensive capability. Out of the four bonuses you can get in combat - on attack, damage, dodge, and body - attributes give bonuses to at most two of these.

Next post I'll talk about how you go about determining your attribute bonuses to shape the character you want.

Friday, 16 June 2017

Struggling with Attributes

Moving Away From The Big 6*3d6

In Explore I’ve gone through several iterations of attributes, moving further and further away from the traditional big six with 3d6.

Originally I started with the big six but wanted more balanced attributes without resorting to the usual solutions of escalating scores / point buy acrobatics / cookie-cutter stat arrays – I used this method to randomly generate six values 3-18 via 3d6 which always add up to 63 whilst keeping the same distribution as 3D6.

The next iteration was to replace the mental attributes (INT, WIS and CHR) with Memory and Intuition, so as to remove Logic and Personality attributes to make those issues purely down to roleplaying – and to split DEX into Agility and Reflexes.

Next I wanted some correlation between related stats. That’s tricky to resolve, but dropping the 3-18 and instead working only with the bonuses -3 to +3 made it possible. (It was a shame to lose the balanced 3D6 system though). I arranged the attributes in pairs – Strength/Constitution, Agility/Reflexes, Memory/Intuition – where the total sum of bonuses is 0, and each pair differs by no more than 2. Thus if you have STR 1 you cannot have a CON of -2 or -3. This was generated via rolling two D% and using this lookup table.

Using this system I then derived Height and Weight from the stats, which also gave me the consistency between the physical character and their stats.

This is the version I’ve used for the last two years. It works reasonably well, and creates varied, balanced and consistent characters. However when considering Climbing, which is about power-to-weight ratio, I encountered difficulties - when I put the numbers together something wasn't making sense. At this point I realised that if in the real world Height and Weight influence Strength, it would be simpler if it worked that way round in the game.

Taking a step back I bit the bullet and stopped blogging the revised rules, and decided to allow myself to follow any train of thought without worrying about the consequences, to see what I could come up with. Not for the first time I was glad I don't have a Kickstarter to complete!

Sacred Cows

Freed up to consider anything this quickly lead to the germination of a new system, but finalising it to something I'm happy with has been something I’ve been wrestling with on and off for the last five months. As you’ll see, mechanically it is only a slight evolution of the previous system, but the approach is very different. In particular it keeps the key benefit of the previous system - closely related skills still have bonuses which can differ by no more than 2 - and doesn't require any alterations to the rest of the rules (aside from a couple of +3s added to target numbers). In fact, apart from making character creation simpler and more transparent, it doesn't really impact on gameplay.

In the process I’ve ended up with a lot more attributes – something which I’ve previously been quite opposed to – but the reasons behind my opposition to that have evaporated. In addition I’ve removed randomness from character generation – something I’ve had in since day one. Both of these were a bit of a sacred cow, but it was making character creation difficult.

My goals are:
  • Attributes are broad brush bonuses to represent aspects of your character to give consistent characters.
  • Aspects of your character which you role play (problem solving and conversations) are not covered by attributes.
  • I want clarity of what an attribute bonus means – it should tell me something specific about the character.
  • I would like you to be able to choose attribute bonuses based upon what you would like your character to be like - that is without having to make dissociated decisions* during character creation.
  • There should be as small an overlap between attributes as possible.
  • It should be reasonably clear which attributes should give bonuses to skills.
  • I want to keep the same size range for bonuses to skills from attributes – seven steps from worst to best – as that has worked well so far.
  • I want only bonuses not penalties – my group was particularly enthusiastic about this change, despite it being only psychological.
  • It should be possible to excel at activities by having bonuses in different attributes. For example, you can be strong by being tall, or by being well built, or muscled.
  • The skills which have similar bonuses due to taking bonuses from similar attributes should be plausible. For example, acrobatics should be strongly linked to dancing, but not to lock picking.
In some respects it now resembles Rolemaster – which was a surprise as I'm a refugee from Rolemaster – and Size is of course an attribute in Runequest. Nothing is new under the sun – but every journey is different. On the other hand it still strongly resembles the prior system - strongly related skills (those sharing two out of three attributes) can only defer by at most 2 - exactly as before - but this "related skills" concept is now quite wide-ranging.

In the next post I'll unveil the attributes and what skills they apply to, and illustrate with a nifty diagram how I found problems and refined them away (well, I like it anyway!).

*It is often claimed that all character creation is dissociated - what I mean by dissociated character creation is the common situation where you make a choice about an aspect of the character purely based upon the mechanical effectiveness of the choice in the game rules, rather than your character concept.